Help urgent!

[jemdcc]

Hei, people. Need a big favor: can u rate this portraits (1º, 2º, ...)?
It's for a local contest.
If u want to, u can say anything else about them.
Thank u!

http://www.pbase.com/jemdcc/portraits

[framewerkz]

My 2c:

1. Shadow
2. Street Boy
3. Kid
4. Graca
5. School Boy

[azdrew]

Is your monitor calibrated correctly? In Shadow, I can see some dark gray and almost black blotches on the left hand side, maybe the result of some burning/dodging or cloning? If you don't have your monitor set right you might be missing it.

If that were fixed, I'd rate them in this order: Shadow, Kid, Graca, Street Boy, School Boy.

[shawnaphoto]

I would rate them as:

1. Shadow
2. Kid
3. Street boy
4. Graca
5. School boy

But I do agree with the blotches. I see them on Graca, too - maybe the hand is imported from a different picture/different pose? But it needs to be blended in PS.

Good luck!

[shadepuppy]

Blotches on "Shadow" very noticeable on my monitor also.

1. Kid
2. Shadow -- if fixed
3. Street Boy
4.Graça
5. School Boy

[ang1970]

1 Shadow
2 Graca
3 Kid
4 School boy
5 Street boy

[ritchie63]

1° Graça
2° Shadows-BW
3° Kid
4° Street boy
5° Mmm... Where is it ??